So the results are in for the second box from Amazon! Keep in mind that my first box (posted about here) did not go so well even though I was able to review the items before they shipped! Nothing had fit properly and the pictures versus the actual items were not quite the same. So box 1 was a flop but I had high hopes for box 2.
Now of these items, and I think you can see it on my face or in my posture, some were MAJOR flops while others were a success! Let’s break it down by each article of clothing and I will include the link below to the item along with the Amazon photo.
Nanette Nanette Lepore Women’s Ankle Slim Leg Pants (Colonel Mustard) – Retail: $72.45, Prime Wardrobe: $66.67
These pants were an adorable color for fall! I was so excited to get these because I am always looking for great office attire that is in trend with the season. But when I put these on… Yikes. These did not fit me, even though I ordered up a size (normally size 6, ordered size 8) because they are “slim” and I wanted a little extra room. If you look at the stock photo on Amazon (found here), the pants appear to fit a little loose. Yet in reality, they did not. They also did not have any give to them so it showed way too tight around my backside. The length was cute and was surprisingly still ankle length even on me (I almost always have to buy “long” so they fit regularly). I paired this with a plain black t-shirt from Kohl’s and black sandals from Payless (le sigh).
Final answer: Returned.
Nine West Women’s Sleeveless Blouse (Tangerine) – Retail: $Currently Unavailable, Prime Wardrobe: $49.28
This blouse is another color favorite! I was so surprised at how bright it was without being full neon. Pairing with a pair of plain black slacks from Chico’s, I thought the blouse was cute but it did not do me any favors. It did zip up in the back and was a stretchy material. However, the peplum cut just did not fall in the right places. It was short and if I bent over or raised my arms, my midriff would definitely be exposed. Also, it had a weird seam that from the front, made me look busty but from the side, I looked like I reverted back to my teenage years. You can find the Amazon product here.
Final answer: Returned.
Sharagano Women’s Pleated Maxi Dress (Yellow) – Retail: $54.99, Prime Wardrobe: $66.85
This maxi dress (found here on Amazon) is definitely office-appropriate attire while still being elegant. It is very flowy and the pleats give it a very polished look. It zips in the back and has a fabric tie to help cinch the waist. It has a high neckline so you can always dress it up with your favorite draped necklace. It had a liner on the inside so the see-through material was not as see-through, though you would definitely have to wear nude undergarments. Just the right length for heels, and could easily transition to a summer wedding or date night. But I didn’t feel comfortable. The pleats in the bust area were stretched (and I am by no means busty) and it looked like I was a little stuffed – though I wasn’t…in fact I had room! I really wanted to like this dress!
Final answer: Returned.
Calvin Klein Women’s Sleeveless Midi with Asymmetric Hem Dress (Hibiscus Multi) – Retail: $120.27, Prime Wardrobe: $46.42
Pink? Seriously? I am not a fan of pink – in fact, I avoid it like the plague. So right off the bat, I was not a fan of this dress (found on Amazon here), but I figured what the heck – let me get out of my comfort zone. It is a zip closure, with an eyelet hook. The dress is an A-line cut with an asymmetric bottom, though it is hard to see it once the dress is on. Made of polyester and spandex, this is not the most breathable dress but it does have a lot of give, making it one of the more forgiving cuts. There is black & orange color blocking that breaks up the very bright pink.
Final answer: Purchased!
Of the four items above, I cannot believe that the pink dress was the keeper! And in fact, I just wore it for a large presentation this past week and felt super comfortable and elegant – which is particularly great when you have to get ready in less than an hour and you’re awake with the sun! I even received a couple of compliments from my peers!
So am I going to go for box 3? Yes. I will give it another try because scientifically speaking, 1 out of 2 is not statistically significant… Okay. Okay. But seriously, I am going to give Prime Wardrobe one more try before deciding to keep this going to help refresh my closet or end it for a different approach.
With Amazon Prime Wardrobe, I do get to see the items selected for me beforehand and can make some swaps. I also get one week to try the clothes on in the comfort of my own home before I have to ship some, or all, of the clothing back. Shipping is indeed free in both directions and Amazon gives you the return label outright so you don’t have to worry about printing and all that. Also, there is a small “styling charge” that is not applied to your order afterwards – the charge is $4.99 and is non-refundable even if you don’t purchase anything.
As a side note, I have also subscribed to StichFix to see about this subscription service. This is a bit more pricey than Amazon Wardrobe but I wanted to present options! I will post an update as soon as I get my first box – especially since I have no idea what to expect!!
So inquiring minds want to know… Have you tried a clothing subscription service? Which one? Did you like it or did you revert back to standard shopping? If you haven’t tried these services, what is your biggest hesitation?